5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (2023)

The best 50 gallon water heater used to be a necessity for each family, the large capacity enables you to enjoy a soothing bathing time without worrying about running out of hot water. Though being a bit expensive on price, you will find it totally worth thanks to the high energy efficiency.

In this article, we would give out several best 50 gallon water heater and gives you necessary tips on buying guides.

Table of Contents show

What Is the Best 50 Gallon Water Heater?

Comparison Chart of Most Efficient 50 Gallon Water Heater of 2020

Photo Title Price Buy
5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (1) Bradford White BWC RE350T6-1NCWW 50GAL 240V $825.87 Check Latest Price
5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (2) A.O. Smith PNS-50 ProMax Short Electric Water Heater, 50 gal Check Latest Price
5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (3) A.O. Smith XCR-50 ProMax Plus High Efficiency Gas Water Heater, 50 gal Check Latest Price

Best 50 Gallon Water Heater Reviews on the Market

#1. 50 Gallon Electric Hot Water Heater – Rheem MR50245 Marathon Heater

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (4)

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (5)

Features:

  • High energy efficient
  • 20 gallons GPH recovery rate at a 90-degree rise
  • Thermally fused upper element offers protection
  • Brass drain valve for durable and long-lasting
  • Standard replacement parts
  • Polyurethane insulation helps reduce energy consumption

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (6)

#2. Bradford White 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (7)

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (8)

Features:

  • Non-corrosion systems design
  • Cheap reasonable price
  • Available for 120v, 208v, 277v and 480v
  • Limited warranty
  • Compact shape
  • Non-simultaneous
  • 4500 watt elements included

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (9)

#3. A.O.Smith 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (10)

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (11)

(Video) Best Residential Water Heater - Bradford vs Rheem and AO Smith - Twin Plumbing

Features:

  • Permaglas glass coating protects the machine from corrosion
  • Dynaclean diffuser dip tube reduce lime and sediment
  • Stainless steel core safeguards the tank
  • Tamper-resistant brass drain valve included
  • Meets all the regulations of National Appliance Energy Conservation Act

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (12)

#4. 50 Gallon High Efficiency Water Heater – Rheem Platinum Hybrid Smart Tank Heater

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (13)

Features:

  • Premium quality level
  • Valuable product with high energy efficiency
  • Condensate drain system to get rid of water from compressor portion
  • Thoughtful after sale service
  • Long-lasting and durable
  • Cost-saving

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (15)

#5. 50 Gallon High Efficiency Gas Water Heater – A.O.Smith XCR-50 ProMax Heater

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (16)

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (17)

Features:

  • Superior corrosion resistance to industry-standard glass lining
  • Self-powered electronic gas valve
  • Internal microprocessor
  • Enhanced operating parameters
  • Dynaclean diffuser dip tube helps reduce lime
  • Meets all the regulations by the National Appliance Energy Conservation Act

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (18)

Why Use 50 Gallon Water Heater?

There are several reasons why you should use a 50-gallon water heater. It is of a perfect size. It can provide hot water to a couple of people, about three to five people. The supply of enough hot water is something that will not be a worry. About five people can take less than one hour to shower. The cost of running a 50-gallon water heater is also relatively cheaper compared to other water heater gallons.

Is A 50 Gallon Water Heater Fit For Me?

Most residential houses use the 50-gallon water heater. It is the most common and popular size. This is because it usually meets the hot water needs for most apartments of about 1 to 2 bedroom homes. If your house of this size, then 50 gallons water heater will fit you. Because of its simultaneous use, it will also be the best.

How to Calculate My Needs on Hot Water?

There is a method called first-hour rating, which can help you know the size of the water heater tank you need. The first-hour rating is the number of gallons of hot water that can be supplied per hour. With the first hour rating, you will be able to know how many gallons you will need. Every heater has a first-hour rating displayed, mostly on the left corner of the Energy Guide sticker.

The 50-gallon water heater is likely to achieve a first-hour rating ranging between 70-80 gallons for gas, but about 60 gallons for electric. Let’s say, you have four people in your household who take a shower simultaneously in the morning. You would need a system with a 60-gallon first-hour rating.

To know your need of hot water best; you will determine the time of day most of the hot water is used in your house, know the number of people using hot water in your home, average hot water used during peak hour, choose a tank with a first hour rating that matches your peak hour demand.

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (19)

Features of 50 Gallons Water Heater

Best 50-gallon water heaters are stainless

They are stainless and durable. They as well eliminate the need for the anode rod. Issues of corrosion and development of bacteria, even the scale build-up, is a forgotten case.

Heavy-duty insulation

Heavy-duty insulation helps to retain heat in the heater for longer. This helps in more savings. It will take longer before the water cools down.

Good tank capacity

The capacity of the best 50-gallon water heater is much friendly, economical, and affordable. It provides enough water for a young family, maybe of 4 to 5 people.

High-grade stainless steel

They are made of high-grade stainless steel with low watt density. This makes it more resistant to hard water corrosion and effect. It is also more durable.

(Video) Best 50 Gallon Water Heater Reviews 2022

More economical

They save time and money. The best 50-gallon water heater has a limited lifetime warranty. This is indeed, rare. It ensures many years of high performance water heating.

  • The 8 Best Tankless Electric Water Heater for the Whole House – Cheap Price for Your Money
  • What is the Best Tankless Water Heater for Cottage 2020?
  • Top 7 Best Point of Use Electric Tankless Water Heater Reviews of 2020
  • 5 Best Small Electric Tankless Water Heater Reviews in 2020

Should I Get the Best 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater?

You should get the best 50-gallon electric water heater. They will save you money because they are much cheaper and pocket-friendly. Most of them have lifetime warranty. This will make you enjoy their services for many years.

You will indeed love the best 50-gallon electric water heater because of their capacity. They will accommodate your household conveniently.

It also retains a lot of heat compared to others, because of the material it is made of. This will save you the money you could use on extra energy.

50 Gallon Natural Gas Water Heater vs. Propane

1. Recovery Efficiency

The propane water heater usually provides higher recovery efficiency compared to electric water heaters. The propane heater, therefore, requires to keep less hot water to march the demand. A smaller tank may be needed with a propane water heater compared to an electric heater. This means less energy, thus lower operation cost.

2. Fuel and Energy Cost

Typically, the cost involved in the operation of a propane water heater is higher compared to an electric heater. Propane shortages have driven up fuel costs, making it more expensive.

3. Calculations

The calculation of the cost of operation of the propane water heater is slightly tricky compared to the estimate of an electric water heater.

50 Gallon Water Heater Prices

You need not shower with cold water, and you can get a new water heater conveniently. Base on your household size, you can get one. There are several options to choose from.

40 to 50-gallon tank electric water heater can be approximately $150 to 1,500. A gas water heater can go for $300 to $600, depending on energy efficiency. Installation fee between $200 to $400 may apply in addition.

The cost of $200 to $900 applies to an electrically heated unit that allows 4 to 5 gallons of heated water per minute. The same amount of gas heated unit costs around $200 and $500. Between $300 and $900 of installation fee may apply.

A solar-powered water heater can cost you around $2,000 and $6,000, installation included. It may be a bit expensive, but it has more advantages.

Consideration of Getting the Best 50 Gallon Water Heater

Starting groundwater temperature

There may be a need for you to be sure of your home size when if you are using tankless electric water heaters. Groundwater temperature is since that is where to start. In a colder climate, it is going to require more power to achieve an average shower temperature.

Amount of hot water you use at a time

The amount of water you require at a given time is a factor. You need to make the best choice of the tank that will fit you and your family without stress. Low flow fixtures are always recommended since some tanks do run out of hot water when they get to high flow fixtures.

Location of water heater

Your water heater should be on point at a central position. If not, maybe you should consider changing it. You may have to take a long time waiting for the hot water to get to your master bath. Or, run out of hot water very first.

Fuel source

The fuel source is a significant factor of consideration. You can decide to use either propane, natural gas, or electricity. Propane may be quite higher in cost compared to natural gas or electricity.

Again most homes have more access to electricity than gas when you have more power that will translate to more hot water.

Final Pick: Top 3 Best 50 Gallon Water Heaters

Photo

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (20)

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (21)

Rating

Prime Status

Price

$825.87

Photo

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (22)

Rating

(Video) Replace Your Water Heater Yourself in 10 Easy Steps

Prime Status

Price

$825.87

Photo

5 Best 50 Gallon Electric & Propane Hot Water Heater – Prices & Costs Compare | Heaters For Life (23)

Rating

Prime Status

Price

Buy Now

Check Latest Price

(Video) Best 50-Gallon Gas Water Heater Reviews (2022 Buyers Guide)

FAQs

Which is more cost effective propane or electric water heater? ›

Lower total cost of ownership – When you consider the lower cost to install and maintain propane equipment and its longer life span (see #4 below), a propane water heater comes out ahead in long-term energy savings, with a total cost of ownership of about 30 percent less than electric-powered water heaters.

What is the best rated 50 gallon electric hot water heater? ›

Best 50 gallon electric water heater

We looked at every 50 gallon electric water on the market and our favorite is the Rheem Performance 50 Gal. Electric Tank Water Heater. This model is about $250 cheaper than the Bradford White 50 gallon electric hot water heater.

What is the most reliable brand of hot water heater? ›

The Rheem Marathon is the best electric water heater on the market today. Its guaranteed 40-year life-span implies it will be the last water heater purchased by homeowners, avoiding the need to replace a water heater every 10 years.

How much is a new 50 gallon electric water heater? ›

A 50-gallon water heater costs around $1,000 for an electric heater and $1,200 for a natural gas heater of the same capacity.

Which is cheaper to heat with propane or electric? ›

Propane is cheaper than electric.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, heating a home in the U.S. with a propane heating system costs far less than heating with an electric system.

Is it worth switching from electric to propane? ›

Because propane is a more efficient fuel, it costs less to operate. Propane appliances also generally have a longer lifespan than their electric counterparts, saving you both money and peace of mind in the long run.

What water heaters do plumbers recommend? ›

...a gas tankless water heater or heat pump water heater could work well for you. Both gas tankless water heaters and heat pump water heaters work well for households who don't have a high demand for hot water at any given time. And both can provide considerable savings on water heating bills.

What is the life expectancy of a 50-gallon electric water heater? ›

A 50-gallon water heater will last about 8 to 20 years, which is longer than most water heaters. An extra 10 gallons might not seem like a huge difference. But choosing a 50-gallon water heater also means choosing a more cost-efficient water heater.

What is the number 1 hot water heater? ›

Our best overall picks are the Rheem Performance 40 Gal. Natural Gas Tall Water Heater and the Rheem Performance Plus 50 Gal. Electric Water Heater, both of which offer large capacity, durability, and longevity.

Which water heaters last the longest? ›

Tank-style water heaters typically last between eight to 12 years, but a water heater can last longer with proper care and maintenance. A tankless water heater usually lasts 20 or more years because it doesn't contend with corrosion issues like a tank-style water heater.

What is the most cost effective electric water heater? ›

Tankless water heaters, as you probably guessed, have no tank. Instead, the device houses coils that superheat the water as it passes through the mechanism to its destination. The result is on-demand hot water that rarely runs out, making it one of the most energy-efficient ways to heat water in your home.

What is the downside of an electric water heater? ›

Electric Heater Disadvantages

Usually has a more expensive maintenance cost. Won't work during power outages unless there is a power source. Heats less water per hour.

What is the most common problem with electric water heaters? ›

One of the most common problems with electric water heaters is a failed heating element, which results in little to no heat production. Fortunately, it is an inexpensive part that is relatively easy to replace with DIY water heater repair.

Is a new water heater tax deductible? ›

Water heaters, air conditioners, and certain stoves qualify for a 30 percent tax credit when you upgrade to newer, more-efficient models.

What is the cheapest way to heat water? ›

Usually natural gas is the cheapest way to heat water, followed by electricity, with propane being the most expensive.

Is it now cheaper to heat water with gas or electric? ›

Gas water heaters are cheaper to use than electric heaters because, on average, gas is cheaper than electricity. You'll spend more money using an electric heater than a gas heater. Gas water heaters also heat water faster than electric units and are helpful in a power outage.

Do electric water heaters use a lot of electricity? ›

Water heaters are among the highest energy-consuming appliances in your home. Energy star predicts that households spend between $400 and $600 on heating water every year for things like laundry, showers, and washing dishes, making water heaters the second most energy-consuming appliance in your home.

Which is cheaper to run electric or propane tankless water heater? ›

As a general rule, gas and electric tankless water heaters will cost approximately the same to operate, especially when you factor in the recommended annual maintenance that gas appliances require. This will depend greatly on the differential between natural gas or propane and electricity costs in your area.

Videos

1. Common Water Heater Myths Answered | Ask This Old House
(This Old House)
2. 3 Things They Don’t Tell You About Tankless
(Matt Risinger)
3. What's The Best Water Heater Sold At Lowe's?
(Matt Risinger)
4. Tankless VS Tank Water Heater...3 Myths DEBUNKED! - Twin Plumbing
(Twin Home Experts)
5. What Size Water Heater Do I Need? Solved! | Water Heaters 101
(Roger Wakefield)
6. Best Gas Water Heater 2022 | Top 3 Picks Reviewed
(Consumer Sherpa)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Neely Ledner

Last Updated: 03/23/2023

Views: 6204

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Neely Ledner

Birthday: 1998-06-09

Address: 443 Barrows Terrace, New Jodyberg, CO 57462-5329

Phone: +2433516856029

Job: Central Legal Facilitator

Hobby: Backpacking, Jogging, Magic, Driving, Macrame, Embroidery, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Neely Ledner, I am a bright, determined, beautiful, adventurous, adventurous, spotless, calm person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.